Comparing bitcoin custody
Multisig, exchange or solo: who can move your bitcoin?
There are three common ways to hold bitcoin. Each answers the same question differently: who holds the keys, and so who can move it. Here they are side by side.
Three ways to hold bitcoin
On an exchange
- Who holds the keys
- The exchange.
- Who can move your bitcoin
- The exchange, on your instructions and subject to its terms.
- If you lose a device or password
- You recover your account through the exchange.
- If the company fails or is hacked
- Your bitcoin is caught up in what happens to the company. Withdrawals can be paused.
- Who helps you
- The exchange’s support team.
- What you have to do yourself
- Keep your account secure.
On your own, single key
- Who holds the keys
- You, one key on one device.
- Who can move your bitcoin
- You, or anyone who gets that one key.
- If you lose a device or password
- You restore from your seed backup. Without it, the bitcoin is gone.
- If the company fails or is hacked
- No company holds anything, so nothing changes.
- Who helps you
- No one.
- What you have to do yourself
- Everything: devices, backups, security and planning for your estate.
Multisig, with btcvaults
- Who holds the keys
- You hold the majority; your adviser and a co-signer hold the rest. btcvaults holds none.
- Who can move your bitcoin
- Only you, with the majority of the keys. Not your adviser, not us.
- If you lose a device or password
- A spare key covers it, and your adviser helps you replace it.
- If the company fails or is hacked
- You keep spending, with your backup pack and enough of your own devices.
- Who helps you
- Your adviser, a professional beside you.
- What you have to do yourself
- Keep your own devices and seed backups safe, and read each payment on your device before you sign.
Which suits what
An exchange
Convenient for buying, selling and small amounts you trade often. The trade-off is that the exchange holds the keys, so your bitcoin depends on the exchange.
A single key of your own
No company holds anything, which is why many people choose it. The trade-off is that you are the single point of failure: one lost device without a working backup, or one stolen seed, and the bitcoin is gone.
A multisig vault with an adviser
For holdings that matter, kept for the long term. You keep control, a spare key protects you from a single loss, and a professional helps with setup, records, replacement keys and planning. The trade-off is a few more steps when you sign, and a fee for your adviser’s service.
Why multisig changes who can move it
A multisig vault needs several signatures to spend, and that rule is part of the vault itself on the Bitcoin network. No one has to be trusted to follow it, and no company can change it. With btcvaults the rule is always arranged so that you hold the majority of the keys. btcvaults prepares payments and checks signatures, but it holds no key and cannot sign.
That is also why a company failure doesn’t freeze your bitcoin: with your backup pack and enough of your own devices, you can spend in standard bitcoin wallets without btcvaults.
Start with a conversation
btcvaults is offered by invitation to advisory firms, and clients use it through their adviser. Email us with your question. A person reads every email and replies.
or write to hello@btcvaults.com
Does your adviser use btcvaults? If not, share it with them.